Thursday, December 10, 2009

Surreality of Telangana? Its here dude....

Perfect case of atrocious governance leading to a state with worse government. My take and I blurt.

I would like to not to bore you with long thought passages about the latest buzz in every Gult, the new state of Telangana(believe me, they are long and keep getting longer). Everyone must have had a mental image of it. Real for some, surreal for others. Its all real now.

But among the myriad thoughts erupting numerously every second regarding its cause and effect, I have some pressing ones I would like to present.

First thing. Pain. Everyone without prejudice would want our state united. Telangana should not have happened. Who knows.

May be its not so painful after all. Should we take it in the stride?

States were divided on linguistic basis, now its ethnicity? Is the country disintegrating? Where might this go?

And most importantly to serve Telangana's actual purpose, must we not make sure that this does not turn into a hate state, fighting for resources etc.? The most glaring (though highly exaggerated) example of hate lies right beside us, not in principle but in emotion. The fact that Telangana issue even reared its head was because of glaring injustice meted out to them by greedy politicians. So the enmity should end right here. Even its existence is unimaginable.

And it is true that smaller states mean better governance, so you have got hope. The most indigestible fact was about the person who will be its CM! Come on guys, you know of what kind he is. Can you believe hailing him as the father of Telangana, his statues in the state! Comparing him to the indomitable great Potti Sreeramulu! And God seriously forbid, asking for a district on his name! Horrific! I forced my mind to stop such atrocious thoughts. I wouldn't like to see that day. Opportunistic is only a decent word to describe him. All politicians are so, but here is the most audacious example of them. He did fast, but what other option did he have to survive? Another heist and people would have buried him. He also made sure everyday of his fast created inexplicable unrest in the state, claiming innocent lives. Let Telangana form but atleast you should have let him starve for a few more days(some may even say die).

That students were a part of this 'revolution' worries me to no end.

And we should remember that Telangana has to pay for all the new ministries and ornaments created, so does Andhra.

Also ethically and culturally, is Hyderabad really a part of Telangana? Some might say yes, but I was thinking not. Then, suddenly among this haze I struck upon the heart of my misery.

"Where do I stand??!!"

I was dumbstruck. Not exactly an identity crisis, but very very.... you know. Coming back to Hyderabad, I have never seen myself as more than a Hyderabadi. And that too I realised now (I only knew about the Indian feeling till now). Ancestry in Andhra, born and brought up in Telangana and living now in Rayaseema(technically its Vadodara now but..). Moreover all reasons that justify Telangana are not in the context of Hyd. No, I don't want a separate UT, thats too messy. But am sad Hyd got into all of it. It is as much Andhra as Telangana.

Given I have never been affected and it would be unfair for me to undermine the effort and sorrow of millions. But the point is that I am on their side.

Also you have the grave danger of Maoists proliferating in the ensuing confusion. One of the most pressing issues given AP has been the role model in efforts to halt this menace.

Focus will be shifted from development issues no doubt but it has to get back on track asap. And if Telangana fails? Separated states haven't succeeded you know. Well those are thoughts we should not entertain at this time. Its a time for positivity.

Is politics all about sensing opportunities and playing with people's minds? It may go as far as instilling a permanent hate for politicians. This business has gone unpredictable. Some things really are out of our hands. May be I should'nt care and hope for the best. But remotely, some part of me is overwhelmed by sadness. Hope that will turn out to be unnecessary

Or maybe its our responsibility to force incompetent and/or unethical people into taking good decisions.

And over the years, the Telangana issue has garnered so many variables, some paradoxical, into its equation that it becomes deliriously confusing for single person, especially with my knowledge of it, to analyse and contemplate the whole of it in a lifetime.

Whats incredibly pathetic is the fact that politicians allowed Telangana movement since 1969!!! The reason is injustice and bad governance(thats what they say. If the reason is purely ethnicity, GOD help India). They could have focused and developed Telangana. Every single sod knows that and yet they let it happen! It is in the hands of the government bloody! A rise in movement, subdue it. Somehow. Another rise, subdue it again. But why the heck won't you prevent it from happening. Four decades is so much!

As I saw people around me and their opinions, it was majorly No with some Yes's to separate Telangana. But then something in both their tones revealed the same feeling, their concern for progress and development. 'Abhivruddhi' seems to be a word politicians use only while speaking, that too rarely. So I think the best thing would be to take what happens as good and move on. It may take a while. Remember the foremost function - fulfilling the purpose of its formation. It is not victory yet; it is a step, irrespective of right or wrong(we've crossed that line), which we should all make sure progresses to a success.

But one(silver lining) fact is it may be a long time before it actually comes into existence. Congress will delay it as long as it is politically possible.

But like the border now carved across Telugu heartland, the scar will always remain.

More in mind. But suffice with what you read. The thing is, am too sad to voice absolutes. Ah, I so didn't want it. Anyways.

Jai Telangana, Jai Andhra

Jai Hind!


(I have thus edited the post 7 times. It up to date now, don't worry :P)

9 comments:

  1. nice one ra..all our centiments very precisely put into words.lets hope for the best!

    ReplyDelete
  2. bloody politicians.....no words..
    i am proud to be a hyderabadi...and will be, no matter which state it is in

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm practically an outsider to this issue but involved as I've been in Hyd for 2 months now and will be for quite some time in the future.

    As a neutral observer, I can't see the point to this division at all. Makes no sense.

    One man goes on a hunger strike and gets his own state. Makes the whole constitution, the legislature, the entire Indian System seem like a joke!

    This seems to be nothing more than grabbing an opportunity that came up after YSR's death as there was no clear leader for the united AP cause.

    Also, the decision about the fate of Hyd won't be easy. Both states are going to fight with their full might as Hyd means a lot of revenue to the state, whichever that turns out to be.

    I guess we Indians really do love partitions.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really don't want it get separated.. No one would want it to .. As mentioned.. it is THE thought of that great person who wanted a united Andhra... Well, even if I don't sing the song "maa telugu thalliki" so often.. it would hurt me to listen it not for Andhra Pradesh as such.. I have known it as Andhra.. I would love to hear it as Andhra and nothing else...!! At this far a distance... it is hurting to realise the fact that Andhra is breaking ... !

    Thanks for the blog... That was really nice..!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dude,
    this is the most baseless article u have written till now. YOu think Telangana movement started in 1969? Brush up your basics. It was much before that time were the Gentleman's agreement, First SRC etc?

    Bcoz KCR is bad, you don't want Telangana? FUnny thing. Any movement shouldn't be stopped coz some1 worthless is getting the credit. After all, movements are not about thinking who is getting the credit etc. Let the unworthy get credit, but still, the goal should be achieved. Its about Telangana state. Not about KCR's Telangana state.

    Its not just students who took part in it. THere were lawyers, doctors, police,teachers(including VCs) etc who gave the support. Its the opinion of intellectuals.

    If u say about Maoism, that sure will be there. But u can't say I don't want to make an airplane coz ther ewill be problem of hijackers. Every problem will get its own solution. And by saying, Maoism will come into existence, you are claiming that Telangana is incompetent. THen how can u sya the region is being developed?

    Agree upon u that the Govt.s' negligence has led to the high raise of Telangana movement. Its their own self-killing. Now the state should be inevitable.

    And remember, whatever KCR may say, peopel of Telangana are not going to hurt the settlers and Hyderabad would mostly be like another Bangalore where ppl of other states live peacefully.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Before anything, (up) this is Saala for you :P
    Well written dude, but i felt you've given your opinion keeping our Hyd in mind, in that case you wouldnt understand the real Telangana Emotion in big picture. It was suppressed so much that people got used to it. And it hardly made any significant difference in our everyday lives. But then when you see all this in a big picture considering all the other telangana districts it is easy to make what they've been robbed of. A clear discrimination or the regional bias or partiality or watevr you name it, at jobs, govt. contracts, college admissions etc can be observed to be the main source of this seeable difference in the lifestyle of both regions. Well... KCR took the first step in this movement( be for watever selfish reasons) but the movement continued only because the entire telangana were for it can't be denied. There is no doubt KCR has turned a hero overnight but then on a long run I'm sure people would'nt consider him one.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Pavan here..

    @sala
    I am not the Chief Negotiator for division of States in Andhra Pradesh. This is what I felt.

    You don't get it do you. First point regarding Telangana, I meant that it should be formed only if we couldn't help it.

    As i said in the blog, if the primary basis of division is ethnicity, GOD help India coz it will disintegrate. No doubt about that. Such problems have to be sorted out. There is no other way. You can't remain charged up and emotional for decisions that will effect generations.

    And if you say that 'No, its coz of the injustice done' then the politicians are to blame for enraging and manipulating public for their own beds for so long. Then it not baseless but obvious that I should remark in the way I did.

    And 1969 is as far as I remember, it took a more violent turn. Thats whn i think it officially became important, ain't it?

    And even though you say that about KCR, I don't think Telangana is going to develop any soon under him. I am positive on it. And thats what I blogged. I won't say its a reason to not divide but you must agree its an undeniable fact (How dare anyone compare him to Sreeramulu, isn't it a shame for all Telugu people?). Telangana might just be a temporary cure, which I pray is not.

    Also you think KCR will be forgotten(as long as TRS is alive?). You know thats what Einstein said about Hitler in early 1930s. What happened? They feed on crisis. Watch him becoming a hero, curse your life. You have sacifice some for a new state, ok, I agree.

    And in the same vein, Maoism is a threat. There is nothing wrong in mentioning it.

    You say they are not going to hurt settlers, how sure can you be of that? Coz I know first hand that the Andhra-Telangana sentiment runs deep. That was my worry about hatred. What if someone senses another bloody opportunity and opens something like MNS in future. Coz undeniably, may be due to more resources or opportunity, Hyd is the breeding ground of the whole state, all regions alike. I may not like what ensues.

    You may say, 'So what do you want us to do?'. Did anyone try to bury the hatred and start fresh. Maybe try respecting each other? How do you think the movement lasted for so may generations. Leave it, we'll go nowhere.

    I am the new generation and I probably don't have complete knowledge of people's misery. The country is in danger of disintegrating. But I am ready to bury my feelings, go by people's vote and look for good relations. And progress Are you?

    ReplyDelete
  8. @INTELLECTUALS SUPPORTING SEPARATION

    One of the greatest mistakes of 20th century is Partition of India And Pakistan and Pakistan should be still repenting for that and Now we are trying to commit a similar mistake here (no offence please, not comparing anyone, but just emphasizing the issues with separation).
    Can anyone of these Intellectuals promise faster development with separation?
    I think most of us know of this 610 G.O. which enforces ppl of one region to work in their region (with exception of Hyderabad-not sure). Every region's students are having 80 or so % reservations in their respective domiciles.
    How does separation ensure INCREASE IN ENROLLMENT OF students in PRIMARY EDUCATION which in a way reflects the number of applicants for govt. jobs? So is it ok for a teacher to be under-qualified if he is from one particular region?
    We will have many issues after separation mainly water sharing, which are very complex. What I would like to stress is, there are issues which are to be solved. But saying partition is the ONLY way of solving them makes things even more complex. Why only demand for a separate state?? Why not demand for something concrete, say some special package for Telangana with the assurance of central govt. (like Bundelkhand in UP). Even if there were separation, do we have any concrete plan in place to assure development? And if we are leaving that to politicians even after separation, then GOD save us!!!! I am one for a united state.
    Jai Telangana! Jai Jai Andhra Pradesh

    ReplyDelete